Why We Stopped Using Welcome Discounts as Our First Touch
Discount-first attracts discount-seekers
Customers who join for a discount stay for discounts. LTV is 30-50% lower than customers who join for the brand.
Alternative hooks
Early access, founder story, free guide, 'be the first to know' list. All outperform discount-first on long-term value.
Discount later, not first
Offer the discount at email 3-4. By then they're in the brand. Conversion is higher and customer quality is better.